A 14-year-old student from Plymouth, Michigan, claims that a teacher told her to “go back to your country” after she chose to sit during the Pledge of Allegiance. The incident, which occurred at East Middle School on January 10, 2025, has drawn national attention and sparked outrage from civil rights groups and local communities.
Danielle Khalaf, an 8th grader, explained that her decision to sit during the Pledge stemmed from her discomfort with the ongoing situation in Palestine. “I decided I wanted to sit down because I didn’t feel comfortable standing because of what’s happening in Palestine,” Danielle said. As reported by WXYZ Detroit, the incident began when the Pledge of Allegiance was played over the school’s loudspeakers, and Danielle opted to remain seated. Afterward, the teacher allegedly addressed the class, labeling those who sat as disrespectful to both soldiers and America.
Teacher’s response fuels controversy
After class, Danielle approached the teacher to explain her reasons for sitting, but according to Danielle, the teacher “spoke over her continuously” and eventually said, “Since you live in this country and enjoy its freedom, if you don’t like it, you should go back to [your] country.” Danielle told WXYZ Detroit that this comment caused her to break down in tears and run out of the room, where she sought support from another teacher and then visited the counselor’s office.
The student’s father, Jacob Khalaf, expressed his distress over the teacher’s response, stating, “Their only solution was to put my daughter in a different class as opposed to doing anything with the teacher.” He also mentioned that the school did not inform them about any disciplinary actions taken, leaving the family concerned about the lack of accountability.
School district’s reaction and civil rights response
In response to the incident, Plymouth-Canton Community Schools issued a statement asserting that discrimination would not be tolerated. “The safety and well-being of our students and staff remain our top priority,” the district said, as reported by WXYZ Detroit. They also confirmed that an investigation had been conducted, but because it was a personnel matter, they could not provide details regarding the teacher’s actions.
The Arab American Civil Rights League (ACRL) held a press conference demanding action against the teacher, calling the incident a violation of Danielle’s First Amendment rights. As quoted by WXYZ Detroit, ACRL Executive Director Mariam Charara said that while the teacher and other students underwent restorative practices, Danielle was excluded from these sessions. The ACRL has filed a formal complaint with the Michigan Department of Civil Rights and warned of potential legal action if the school does not take further steps.
Danielle’s father and the ACRL continue to call for the teacher’s removal, with Jacob Khalaf emphasizing that the incident was deeply traumatic for his daughter. “It was traumatizing, it hurt, and I know she could do that to other people,” Danielle added, as reported by WXYZ Detroit.
